Dominants – Or Not?

So, you have some communities of ants. You notice that some communities are more diverse than others. In one community, certain species of ants are more common, while in another, different species are more common. How can you explain this coexistence and variation? Dominance hierarchies, perhaps?

Ants
Ants at war. Image: Alex Wild

Dominance hierarchies have played a key role in ant ecology for many years. These hierarchies describe the relative ability of each species in a community to dominate over others, and tend to be constructed as a single, linear list. In other words, Species A is dominant over Species B which is dominant over Species C which is dominant over blah blah blah. Such a dominance structure is thought to impact species coexistence and variation in community composition across different habitats.

But wait! A recent review and discussion by Dr. Katie Stuble and colleagues challenges this paradigm of dominance hierarchies, suggesting that myrmecologists must improve and move beyond the use of such hierarchies to better explain the processes that structure ant communities. The researchers argue that the most common metrics employed to assess dominance (based on factors ranging from one-on-one aggression to control of food baits) differ in their ecological implications and, critically, are inconsistent in their findings when used on identical sets of data. Furthermore, the concept of a strict dominance hierarchy is unlikely to adequately describe the dynamic and complex nature of real ecological communities. They also offer some suggestions for enhancing future work, including explicitly defining “dominance” and incorporating network theory in studies of dominance, as well as abandoning any uniform application of dominance hierarchies altogether. Check out the paper for more!

4 thoughts on “Dominants – Or Not?

Add yours

  1. Do you think that a better understanding of how ant communities relate to one another might help us to understand how human communities relate to one another?

    Like

    1. On a certain level, sure. But insects have a much different behavior from mammals, they are run by very basic instincts. Their simple neural architecture makes ants resilient but ultimately predictable.

      Did you know the human population is decreasing in countries with high standards of living? You’d never see this in an ant colony unless as a consequence to some natural disaster.

      Like

      1. Interesting!
        I wonder if the decrease in human populations that you mentioned is indeed ‘natural’. Don’t humans mature faster in prosperous communities? If this is true-as I have always believed-then it is in our best interest as a species to raise more children in those societies that are well-off.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: